I had been meaning to read Fun Home by Alison Bechdel for a long time. I mean, this is the woman who brought us the Bechdel Test, which is a pretty important part of my feminist, pop-culture loving worldview. And Fun Home is her most famous book. So clearly this was something I needed to read. After doing so, I’m still not entirely sure what to make of this strange little book.
For those not in the know, Fun Home is a memoir about Bechdel’s growing up and coming out as a lesbian while also dealing with the suicide of her closeted father. It’s heavy and intensely private, but demonstrates the synergistic power a really good graphic novel can harness. The story Bechdel is telling is so complicated and difficult that I’m not sure it could be told any other way. The illustrations both keep the novel from sinking under its own weight and give it depth that words alone could not accomplish. Pictures allow Bechdel to say things that might be too painful for words to ever truly grasp. And when it works, it’s so beautiful.
But there’s something about the book that failed to draw my in. Maybe it’s the unfamiliar format – graphic novels are still fairly new to me. Maybe it’s the endless literary allusions. I know it’s an unpopular opinion, or a sign of my ignorance, but sometimes the book felt a little overdone to me. As a frequent over thinker and someone who uses books to understand my life, I probably should have loved this book. But maybe it was too familiar. Maybe her books weren’t my books, so I couldn’t connect. I wanted to, but I didn’t.
But, by the strange benevolence of the universe, my many nerd interests often collide. And while I just read Fun Home, a Broadway musical based on Fun Home is about to start previews in a couple of weeks. Graphic novels may be new and unfamiliar to me, but I’m a theatre nerd from way back. The language of musicals is in my bones. And while I (and many of the people involved in the musical) will admit that this sounds like the last story on Earth that should really be a musical (ok, maybe that’s Blood Meridian), it works. In the same way that illustrations allow Bechdel to say things that words cannot, Jeanine Tesori’s music captured for me things that I couldn’t get from the book. Listening to the songs from the musical somehow brought everything I just read to life. There they are. That same strange, beautiful, terrible, tragic family. There’s the contradictions, there’s the sad coincidences. They’re distilled not by images on a page, but by quivering notes and poignant silences. And I have to say, it’s beautiful.